There are tons of Butter Chicken recipes out there. I’ve tried at least 6 different variations, and think I’ve finally arrived at my favourite. Here goes:
- Prep your meat. I like to use chicken thighs and drumsticks (on the bone) for this recipe. Skin the chicken, and make slits on each piece so that your marinade will go all the way in.
- Marinate 500 gm chicken in 3 tbsp yoghurt, 1 tbsp Ginger Garlic paste, salt, 2 tsp red chili powder & the juice from half a lime. Mix well and set aside for at least 30 min
- When you’re ready to cook, heat 1 tsp canola oil + 1 tsp butter in a heavy bottomed dish. Add the chicken, and all the marinade and cook on high heat till you see a nice brown sear on all sides. Should take about 5 min.
- Turn the heat down to medium, slam a lid on, and let the chicken cook. You can add a splash of water if it’s looking too dry but ideally the yogurt should give you all the liquid you need. The chicken needs to cook for 30 min. 15 minutes in, open the pan and give it a mix and cover again.
- Once the chicken has started to fall off the bone, turn off the heat and let the dish stand.
- In a pan / wok, heat 1 tsp canola oil + 1 tsp butter. Using oil and butter together will prevent the butter from burning.
- Add one large chopped onion, two chopped large red tomatoes, 12 – 15 cashew nuts, 2 tbsp watermelon seeds, 1 tbsp Ginger Garlic paste. Cook till the tomatoes look mushy and break down.
- Cool and puree this mixture in a blender. If you want a really fine gravy, pass the puree through a strainer. I like a little bit of texture to my gravy so leave it as it is.
- Heat 1 tsp oil + butter in a wok and add all the puree
- Add 1 tsp Turmeric, 3 tsp of Kashmiri Red Chilli Powder, 1 tbsp Coriander Powder, and 1 tsp of Garam Masala powder. Keep stirring on high heat for at least 5 min. Things will splutter, but that’s okay.
- Add 2 tbsp of ketchup. This is optional, but I feel like the ketchup has nice hits of sweetness and acidity and rounds off the dish quite well.
- Add 2 tbsp of cream and cook the gravy till it looks rich and shiny.
- Crumble 1 tbsp of Kasuri Methi (dry fenugreek leaves) on top. If your leaves feel soft, toast them gently in pan for about a minute and gently powder them over your dish.
NOTE: It is super important that you use Kashmiri Red Chilli for this dish. This chilli is low on heat and big on colour, and it what gives Butter Chicken that lovely shade of orange.
- Add the cooked chicken to the gravy. Be damn sure not to waste any of those glorious juices in the pan, okay?
- Mix gently on medium heat, and check seasoning.
- Add another dash of cream and turn off the heat.
THE SMOKE (DHUNGAR)
- This is where things get really interesting
- Heat a small piece of charcoal on a open fire
- Once glowing, put the charcoal into a little steel / clay bowl and very carefully place the bowl inside the dish of Butter Chicken
- Pour 1/2 tsp ghee on top of the coal and immediately put a lid on the dish
- The dish will fill up with smoke and start infusing the Butter Chicken with that wonderful Tandoori aroma
- Open the dish once all the smoke has disappeared
- Garnish with a final dusting of Kasuri Methi, a drizzle of cream, and serve with Naan or a simple rice dish like Onion Pulao or Peas Pulao.
Over and out!